CLEMSON — Dabo Swinney said Tuesday the SEC officiating crew during Clemson’s victory against USC last season approved beforehand the trick play that led to Jacoby Ford’s 50-yard touchdown catch.
Meanwhile, the SEC’s director of football officials, Rogers Redding, said his crew never raised the question of the play’s legality afterward. Nor was the play critiqued in the postgame officials evaluation, in part because USC did not question its legality.
The play included the same deception as Marquan Jones’ 37-yard catch Thursday night against Georgia Tech — and one of two plays ACC coordinator of football officials Doug Rhoads said Monday should have been flagged and nullified for violating a rule prohibiting substitution tactics that may confuse opponents.
Last year, Clemson led 10-0 early in the second quarter when Ford moved toward the sideline and stopped on the field to tie his shoelaces. He wasn’t spotted by defenders until making the catch and wound up eluding two defenders for the score.
Redding declined to provide the SEC’s interpretation because he doesn’t recall having seen either play, adding that most of the buzz from his officials has centered on Georgia Tech’s fake field goal — also deemed illegal by the ACC.
“The rule book is guilty about being vague and ambiguous in some places, but in these places it is amazingly clear,” Redding said.
Swinney said that during his standard pregame meeting with officials, he went over the logistics of the play and was told it was legal under two conditions: 1) No offensive player was actually substituted, and; 2) All offensive players were inside the painted yardage numbers when the ball was spotted to initiate the 40-second play clock.
“My understanding was that if you have the same personnel on the field ... then as long as you’re in the numbers when the ball’s put in play, then hey, it’s not my job to count to 11 for them,” Swinney said. “That’s their job. That’s the way I understood the rule.”
Swinney questioned the legality of Georgia Tech’s first-quarter touchdown pass off the fake field goal — the Yellow Jackets had substituted a hefty portion of their lineup to get the field-goal unit on, save for receiver Demaryius Thomas, who stayed on the field but hid near the sideline.
“I thought it was illegal at the time, but I couldn’t get anybody to listen to me,” Swinney said.
Hip hop. Senior tight end Michael Palmer is listed as probable with a hip injury.
Palmer hurt the hip during practice two weeks ago and re-injured it making a sideline catch late against Georgia Tech. An X-ray taken earlier this week determined no bone was broken.
Asked if he would play, Palmer grinned and responded, “Ask me tomorrow.”
Snap count. Swinney said a number of second-stringers were held out against Georgia Tech because the staff decided to stick with its best players when the first quarter did not go as planned.
However, offensive coordinator Billy Napier said the staff realized a mistake had been made upon learning Jones logged a mere three snaps.
“When the game was all said and done, we lost track that he hadn’t played enough,” Napier said. “That’s our job to get him out there. He’ll play a lot more than that each game.”
Swinney said the Tigers also intend to weave redshirt freshman Jaron Brown back into the mix.
Reading between the line. Swinney was asked whether he said anything to encourage lineman Thomas Austin, whose controversial holding call negated a long pass to Jacoby Ford that would have put the Tigers in position for the go-ahead score with 3:14 left.
“One of the things I do in Monday team meetings is I go over the penalty tape with them,” Swinney said.
“We went over the penalty tape,” he added, “and I encouraged him. They called a hold. So I’m sure there was a hold in there somewhere. I encouraged him to keep playing like he’s playing.”
We encourage an open – and civil – exchange of affirming and dissenting opinions on our stories. We invite you to respectfully comment on our content as part of our interactive community.
Click here to read our comment guidelines and learn about our commenting system. Report abuse by clicking the "Report Abuse" link.
You must be signed in to comment. You can sign in using your account at thestate.com or your Facebook, Twitter or Disqus accounts.
If you are logged in and still unable to comment, you might need to log out and log back in, delete your browser's stored cookies or change your browser's cookie settings to allow "third-party" cookies.
For more on managing browser cookies, view our help document here.
How do I report abuse on comments I deem inappropriate?
Yes. Report abuse by clicking the "Flag" button.
What are some of the features of Disqus commenting?
You can select how comment threads are organized. Some people prefer to read the newest comments first, while others prefer to read the oldest comments first. Others prefer to sort on comments that have the best rating (highest number of "likes") or are the most popular now (highest number of "likes" and replies). The choice will be yours. You can lock in your personal preference by selecting from among the options presented in the "Sort by" drop down menu that appears above the comments you are reading. This setting follows you across the site as your read articles and can be changed at your convenience.
You will have the option of subscribing via email to a comment thread by clicking the "Subscribe by email" button at the bottom of the comment box. New comments will be sent directly to your email inbox, where you may read and respond by email.
You will be able to subscribe via RSS to a comment thread by clicking the "Subscribe by RSS" button at the bottom of the comment box. This link will include step-by-step instructions on how to set up the RSS subscription.
If you are logged in using your Facebook account, you will be able to share your comments on specific articles to your Facebook profile page, just by clicking the "Share on Facebook" link directly beneath the comment box. This is a per-post selection, so each time you comment on an article or reply to another comment, you will need to indicate your interest in sharing the post to Facebook.
Will I need to register?
You can register with thestate.com to comment, or log in with an existing Disqus, Facebook or Twitter account. If you have forgotten your thestate.com username and password, you can have the information resent to you by clicking here.
What about my avatar?
We have created a default avatar for readers that log in using their thestate.com username and password. If you want to display a unique avatar, you can upload one to Disqus, Facebook or Twitter, and then comment on thestate.com stories using that account instead.
Will I be able to indicate my approval of a comment?
Yes, by clicking the button labeled "Like."
Will I be able to "reply" to comments?
Yes. The ability to reply to specific comment posts will remain a core of thestate.com commenting.
We ask that you remain civil, and that you follow these guidelines:
Do not resort to personal abuse. You may disagree with the content of an article, with the reporter or with other readers’ comments, but do not attack anyone personally. Do not libel or defame anyone or violate their privacy.
Keep your comments succinct and stay on topic. Comments that bear no relation to the story will be deleted.
Do not use foul language. Don't try to camouflage profanity with asterisks or other symbols or foreign phrases.
Avoid hate speech. Abusive comments, racist rants or defamatory statements about any group will be deleted.
Do not use threatening language. Repeated bullying or taunting will be cause for banning your account.
Use standard English grammar and observe accepted rules for capitalization, punctuation and spelling. Do not post a comment using all capital letters.
Do not post spam or advertising of any kind.
Do not add images to your comments.
Do not link to Web sites outside of thestate.com.
Do not use an avatar that is offensive or portrays someone in a negative light. Do not misspell or emphasize letters in a person's name to ridicule them or portray them in a negative manner.
Do not report comments as abusive simply because you disagree with them. Report them only if they violate these guidelines.
We reserve the right to delete posts that do not follow these guidelines. Posts that violate these guidelines or are otherwise offensive should be reported immediately. Click the "flag" link under the offending comment.
If a post is determined to have violated the guidelines listed above, it may be (1) blocked or (2) deleted from our system.
Users who continue posting comments that violate these guidelines may, at our discretion, be blocked from submitting future comments as well.