Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
                

Click here to return to our full coverage of the SC Primary

Note: Video is provided as a public service by ETV; video typically is available only when the General Assembly is in session.

Note: Video is provided as a public service by ETV; video typically is available only when the General Assembly is in session.

Note about this video: This content is in the Flash format. If you require an up-to-date version of the Flash plugin, click here to download it.

Having trouble viewing video? Try here for the House or here for the Senate.

Tweets from our government reporting team

News - SC Politics - SC Republican Primary

Thursday, Jan. 12, 2012

Politicians always take off the gloves in S.C.

- gnsmith@thestate.com
Bookmark and Share
email this story to a friend E-Mail print story Print Reprint 0 comments
Text Size:

tool name

close
tool goes here

Now is the time that GOP presidential candidates, vying to be the “Romney alternative” in South Carolina, could take their cues from South Carolina’s history book.

Play dirty.

Boarding a plane to Columbia Wednesday, GOP front-runner Mitt Romney indicated he knows what is coming, saying he is ready to defend himself from the “underbelly” of politics in a state known for bare-knuckled tactics.

  • Dirty South Carolina?

    The Palmetto State has a long history of bare-knuckle politics. A look at some of the more infamous incidents:

    1980: In the first-ever S.C. GOP primary, it looked like Palmetto State voters would picking Texas Gov. John Connelly, who had the endorsement of legendary U.S. Sen. Strom Thurmond. But Ronald Reagan, who had won the New Hampshire primary, had a wild card: Lee Atwater. The infamous Columbia political consultant leaked a claim to the press that Connelly was “trying to buy the black vote.” It hurt Connelly and helped secure Reagan’s win – and the nomination.

    1990: Now-deceased Rod Shealy, one of the state’s most well-known political consultants, was looking to increase the Lowcountry turnout of conservative voters while running his sister’s race for lieutenant governor. Shealy recruited an unemployed African-American fisherman to run for Congress in the primary against incumbent Republican Arthur Ravenel Jr. of Charleston. When the ploy was revealed, Shealy was fined for violating campaign laws.

    2000: By the time John McCain left South Carolina, many GOP primary voters wrongly thought his wife was a drug addict and McCain had fathered an African-American baby because of a whisper campaign.

    2010: State Rep. Nikki Haley, R-Lexington, was trailing three better-funded, more well-known rivals in the GOP gubernatorial primary when two men claimed to have had sex with the married Haley. Haley denied the claims and won the race.

    2010: Robert Cahaly, an adviser to Ken Ard, the GOP nominee for lieutenant governor, was arrested for paying for and disseminating automated telephone calls without disclosing the identity of the originating party to those getting the calls.


Video from around the world

“Politics ain’t bean bags, and I know it’s going to get tough,” the former Massachusetts governor said. “But I know that is sometimes part of the underbelly of politics,”

In South Carolina – with its tradition of whisper campaigns, automated phone calls that no one takes credit for and possibly illegal efforts to sway voters – politics is a blood sport, supported by a cottage-industry of political strategists.

Anticipation is building as to whether the next week and a half, leading up to the state’s first-in-the-South primary, will result in the bare-knuckle tactics for which the state is notorious.

Why can voters anticipate some intense Republican vs. Republican bashing?

• Traditionally, South Carolina is where the gloves come off. Candidates have slugged it out in the two early-voting states – Iowa and New Hampshire – and some are seething mad at the others.

• There is cash to support campaign efforts – clean or dirty – allowing candidates who must make up ground to attack. For example, the super-political action committee supporting former U.S. House Speaker Newt Gingrich, angry at Romney over Gingrich-bashing ads in Iowa, is enjoying a $5 million boost from a casino mogul. Meanwhile, Texas Gov. Rick Perry’s campaign remains flush even as Perry, who has fared poorly thus far, faces the prospect of winning or going home after the Jan. 21 S.C. primary.

• A lot is on the line. Since 1980, the winner of the S.C. GOP primary has gone on to win the Republican nomination every time. The candidate who wins the Palmetto State will get a mighty bounce that far exceeds those from Iowa and New Hampshire.

So will South Carolina live up to its “bad boy” national reputation and play dirty?

Opinions are split.

“History always repeats itself, and this state has the reputation of playing hard,” said Larry Marchant, a political consultant who is not working for any of the presidential candidates. “I expect it to get bare knuckles here.”

Marchant knows. He perhaps is most best-known for his 2010 statement that he had sex with then-gubernatorial candidate Nikki Haley. Marchant offered no proof and Haley, a married mother of two, denied the claim and won the election.

Others doubt the primary will get nasty.

“We are in a new era of communications that doesn’t allow you to get away with the dirty tricks of the past,” said Wes Donehue, a S.C. political consultant who was working for U.S. Rep. Michele Bachmann of Minnesota, until she bowed out of the race after a poor showing in Iowa. “You can’t go anywhere without someone being there with a video camera.”

Donehue knows a thing or two about tricks.

During the 2008 GOP primary, reporters used Internet resources to discover Donehue was behind the PhonyFred.org website, which anonymously attacked Republican candidate Fred Thompson.

But Donehue says hehas seen tricks far more sordid, including a bogus Christmas card sent to the state’s GOP activists during the 2008 race. The card, claiming to be from the Romney family, included controversial quotes from the Book of Mormon.

Today, however, Donehue says super political action committees have become the new way to play rough. A recent U.S. Supreme Court ruling allows unlimited contributions to and spending by the committees as long as they do not coordinate efforts with the actual campaigns.

“The negative attacks won’t be anonymous, whisper campaigns,” Donehue said. “They’ll be on TV for the world to see.”

So far, the most negative S.C. ad is one from a super PAC that supports Gingrich. It portrays Romney as an unsavory capitalist during his tenure at private-equity firm Bain Capital. The ad includes interviews with people who lost their jobs at companies bought by Bain including one in Gaffney.

There are likely to be plenty more negative ads, predicts Richard Quinn, a longtime S.C. Republican consultant, now working for former Utah Gov. Jon Huntsman.

Quinn points to the anti-Gingrich ads run by the super PAC supporting Romney before the Iowa caucuses as proof that negative ads work. “Gingrich was ahead in Iowa according to the polling. But not after those ads. Those attack ads were probably just as relentless and the same level of intensity as the one run against us in 2000.”

Quinn is referring to perhaps South Carolina’s most notorious example of dirty politics.

In 2000, a whisper campaign led many S.C. voters to wrongly think GOP presidential contender John McCain, who Quinn worked for, had fathered an African-American child and his wife was a drug addict.

McCain got the last laugh eight years later, winning the 2008 S.C. GOP primary and going on to capture the Republican nomination.

The Associated Press contributed to this article.

Reach Smith at (803) 771-8658.

Get The State newspaper delivered to your home. Click here to subscribe.

Your comments

We encourage an open – and civil – exchange of affirming and dissenting opinions on our stories. We invite you to respectfully comment on our content as part of our interactive community.

The news you want delivered to your e-mail!

Quick Job Search