SCOTUS | Health care

What it means to doctors and patients

Too much government control?

jholleman@thestate.comJune 29, 2012 

The Affordable Care Act hasn’t changed the doctor-patient interaction yet, and probably won’t in the near future.

But some South Carolina physicians are concerned about the long-term fallout after the U.S. Supreme Court ruled the health care reform constitutional. Eventually the government will control many of decisions on what will be covered by Medicaid, Medicare and, by extension, private insurance, said Dr. Gregory Tarasidis, a Greenwood ear-nose-throat specialist and a past president of the S.C. Medical Association.

Many of those decisions will be made by the Independent Payment Advisory Board, which will not be made up of physicians.

“Bureaucrats will be rationing care based on dollars but not on quality of health care,” Tarasidis said. “Over time, people will see premiums rise. The bureaucracy will create issues, and doctors will begin to retire early.”

Now, physicians make most of the decisions on how to treat patients, what drugs or procedures are best to deal with individual problems. If those choices are severely limited, “you have lost the physician-patient relationship and you have people who are not physicians making decisions about care.”

The medical association hoped the Supreme Court would throw out the entire Affordable Care Act and start over with more physician input.

The S.C. Hospital Association, while saying now is the time to move forward and deal with the act’s provisions, fretted that the call for continued political debate could slow improvements in health care.

“The debate will now intensify as it moves from the courts in the political arena,” said Thornton Kirby, president and CEO of the S.C. Hospital Association. “Patients don’t have the luxury of waiting months and years for political solutions. They need the best care we can give them today, tomorrow, and next week.”

Some people who stayed away from doctors’ offices because they had no insurance will be covered under the act starting in 2014, either under the expansion of Medicaid rolls or through new health insurance exchanges. If the state doesn’t opt out of the Medicaid expansion and if health insurance exchanges open the market to low-income users, many of the nearly 1 million currently uninsured in the state will have more access to health care.

Even if they seldom go to the doctor, they’ll benefit.

“People with health insurance feel healthier, behave in healthy ways, and are more optimistic,” said Columbia health care economist Lynn Bailey. “Knowing you can access care when you are sick without bankrupting your family is a feeling of security. I think South Carolinians deserve that feeling.”


Ruling roundup

What do you think about the ruling? Take our survey

What the SC delegation said

Sampling of quotes

What it means to small business

What it means to doctors and patients

What it means to SC's poor

Winners & losers

Roberts was the big surprise

The State | editorials and opinions

The State is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service