SC’s lone Dem. in DC, GOP split on gun-control in wake of Newtown

jself@thestate.comDecember 21, 2012 

  • What members of the SC delegation in DC are saying

    From U.S. Sen. Lindsey Graham's spokesman Kevin Bishop, compiled from recent media interviews:

    "The question for me is, how do you prevent mass murder? Isn’t that what we’re talking about? I don’t think an assault weapons ban fixes the problem. I don’t feel like that’s going to stop anything. The worst thing we can do is create false sense of security.

    Every bad event in the world can’t be fixed by government action. We live in a dangerous world and it’s always been that way.

    How do you stop somebody from doing what this guy did — shooting his mother in the head and killing a bunch of kids? I guess one way is to take every sharp object out of society. I don’t think it’s very practical to round up and confiscate every gun. It’s also not practical to start arresting and putting in jail people who just appear to be dangerous.

    When people abuse a weapon, I think having additional penalties for a crime committed with a gun makes perfect sense. But we are who we are as Americans. The Second Amendment is engrained in our culture. If my individual rights under the Constitution are limited by the sensibility of others, then I don’t have a whole lot of rights."

    U.S. Rep. Jim Clyburn:

    “I supported the ban on assault weapons and large ammunition magazines in the 1994 Crime Bill and would like to see us revisit that policy and potentially improve upon it. At the same time, I believe that we must be comprehensive in how we react to the Newtown tragedy by considering common sense policies that would also address access to mental health services, support for troubled youth, and improved security measures in our schools."

    U.S. Rep. Mick Mulvaney, S.C.

    “Seeking to lay blame after an unspeakable tragedy is a natural and normal reaction, and such is obviously the case with the recent massacre of the innocents in Newtown, Connecticut. As we struggle to arrive at explanations for the inexplicable, and to lay blame, I hope we focus first and foremost on the individual(s) responsible. To the extent the discussion moves toward broader societal issues, I hope we look at more than just gun control. We must, as a nation, be willing to talk about mental health, the glamorization of violence, the true cost of broken homes, and the general culture of death that permeates our society. Any attempt to single out our constitutional protections and liberties as a cause of this tragedy would be misplaced.

    As the father of triplets, I cannot even begin to imagine – and indeed, do not want to imagine – the loss the families in Newtown have suffered. My thoughts and prayers have been and will continue to be with the victims and families of this tragedy.”

    From U.S. Rep. Joe Wilson's spokesperson Caroline Delleney:

    As far as the horrific massacre occurring in CT last Friday, Congressman Wilson is completely heartbroken over the event and his thoughts and prayers are with the family. Should legislation be proposed surrounding the event, the Congressman will carefully consider them.

— U.S. Rep. Jim Clyburn, South Carolina’s lone Democrat in Washington, is the state’s only member of Congress calling for tighter restrictions on guns, including a ban on assault weapons, a week after a gunman massacred 20 schoolchildren and six adults in Newtown, Conn., before killing himself.

Meanwhile, South Carolina’s Republican congressmen and senators have expressed opposition to proposals to restrict gun rights.

Asked how to stop another Newtown, U.S. Sen. Lindsey Graham said in a statement, “(O)ne way is to take every sharp object out of society.”

But, the Seneca Republican added, that is not practical.

In a statement, Clyburn, from Columbia, said he supports a ban on assault weapons and large-ammunition magazines similar to what was enacted in 1994 under President Bill Clinton. The ban lapsed under President George W. Bush.

Clyburn said he would like to “revisit that policy and potentially improve upon it,” while considering additional policy changes.

“We must be comprehensive in how we react to the Newtown tragedy by considering common-sense policies that would also address access to mental-health services, support for troubled youth and improved security measures in our schools,” he said.

Clyburn’s position is in line with President Barack Obama and Democratic lawmakers who have called for bans on assault weapons and high-capacity ammunition magazines.

Obama announced Wednesday the creation of a gun-violence task force to recommend legislation by January.

What the South Carolinians think is important because any legislation proposed must pass Congress to become law.

The state’s congressional Republicans say the post-Newtown focus should be on mental health and individual responsibility, not new laws.

U.S. Rep. Tim Scott, R-North Charleston, who was appointed to Jim DeMint’s Senate seat this week, said Wednesday he wants to see investigative reports from the shooting before deciding if any new laws are needed.

“It’s hard for us to know what to do at this point,” Scott said. “We have not had enough time to bury the folks in this tragedy. Jumping to conclusions at this time would be inappropriate.”

Graham, the state’s senior congressional Republican, opposes an assault-weapons ban, spokesman Kevin Bishop said.

“I don’t feel like that’s going to stop anything,” Graham said in one statement. “The worst thing we can do is create false sense of security. ...

“I don’t think it’s very practical to round up and confiscate every gun. It’s also not practical to start arresting and putting in jail people who just appear to be dangerous.”

U.S. Rep. Mick Mulvaney, R-Indian Land, warned against singling out gun rights as the nation discusses how to move forward in the wake of the Newtown tragedy.

“Seeking to lay blame after an unspeakable tragedy is a natural and normal reaction,” Mulvaney said in a statement. “As we struggle to arrive at explanations for the inexplicable, and to lay blame, I hope we focus first and foremost on the individual(s) responsible.

“To the extent the discussion moves toward broader societal issues, I hope we look at more than just gun control,” he said. “We must, as a nation, be willing to talk about mental health, the glamorization of violence, the true cost of broken homes and the general culture of death that permeates our society.

“Any attempt to single out our constitutional protections and liberties as a cause of this tragedy would be misplaced,” Mulvaney said.

U.S. Rep. Joe Wilson, R-Springdale, was not available for comment.

But his spokeswoman, Caroline Delleney, said in an email, “As far as the horrific massacre occurring in (Connecticut) last Friday, Congressman Wilson is completely heartbroken over the event and his thoughts and prayers are with the family. Should legislation be proposed surrounding the event, the congressman will carefully consider (it).”

U.S. Sen. Jim DeMint of Greenville, and U.S. Reps. Trey Gowdy of Spartanburg, Jeff Duncan of Laurens and congressmen-elect Tom Rice of Myrtle Beach were not available for comment.

However, since Newtown, the two congressmen and Rice have said the way to curb gun violence may not be with new gun-control legislation.

Reporter Andy Shain contributed to this report. Reach Self at (803)771-8658.

The State is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service