Scott Says

Scott Says: Doomed seasons will end in Superdome

December 30, 2012 


Carolina Panthers' Cam Newton (1) completes a pass to Mike Tolbert (35) despite bing hit by San Diego Chargers' Shaun Phillips (95) and Corey Liuget (94) in the first half at Qualcomm Stadium on December 16, 2012. The Panthers won 31-7. David T. Foster


On Sept.16, Carolina whipped New Orleans 35-27 in its home opener. That led to some premature confidence, as best expressed in a quote from Cam Newton after the game.

“The vibe is changing,” Newton said. “Not only for this team, but for this whole organization.”

Well, no. It didn’t.

The Panthers didn’t win again until November, and by then the season was in shambles and general manager Marty Hurney had lost his job.

The team has since played well for the most part, going 4-1 over their past five games, but the terrible start means the Panthers (6-9) will miss the playoffs for the fourth straight season.

New Orleans is also playing well now, but was likewise doomed by a poor start. The Saints have gone 7-4 since starting 0-4.

Sunday’s game probably won’t look like a contest between two losing teams, but that’s what it ultimately is.

•  In case you missed my earlier column, I am advocating that team owner Jerry Richardson give coach Ron Rivera a third year to try to get the team turned around.

I believe Rivera has gotten better as a coach and that to change out the entire coaching staff again would be a “one step forward, two steps back” approach.

•  The Saints and Panthers have had very similar seasons in several respects besides the slow starts.

They can play beautifully. They are responsible for both of 13-2 Atlanta’s losses this season. And they can play horribly. They are also responsible for 2-13 Kansas City’s two wins.

•  One thing about the Saints: they play entertaining football. Their average score this season is 28-27. The Panthers both score and allow about a touchdown less than that. I think this game will be a high-scoring season finale, and that Carolina will play just well enough to win its fourth straight game. My prediction: Carolina 37, New Orleans 33.

The State is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service