Holder, Duncan announce national guidelines on school discipline

The Washington PostJanuary 9, 2014 

— Federal officials released what were described as the first national guidelines on school discipline Wednesday, urging educators across the country to move away from approaches that suspend students for minor infractions and fall hardest on minority children.

“The need to rethink and redesign school discipline practices is frankly long overdue,” said Education Secretary Arne Duncan, speaking in Baltimore alongside Attorney General Eric Holder as part of a joint federal effort.

The event, at Baltimore’s Frederick Douglass High School, was hosted in a city that officials lauded for a major reduction in student suspensions in recent years. Federal officials also praised Maryland leaders for proposing reforms to state discipline policies, which are expected to come for a vote later this month.

Duncan told the gathered crowd that racial discrimination in school discipline is “a real problem today – it’s not just an issue from 30 or 40 or 50 years ago.” He said the Obama administration is the first to provide national guidance on the issue.

Both Duncan and Holder emphasized that safety and order are a priority in schools but said too many schools resort to suspension, expulsion or arrest for problems that could be handled in more constructive ways.

Offenses that once landed students in a principal’s office now might land them in a police precinct, Holder said.

“Too often, so-called zero-tolerance policies, however well-intentioned they might be, make students feel unwelcome in their own schools; they disrupt the learning process,” Holder said, adding that students could face “lasting negative effects” from harsh treatment and could be at higher risk for future contact with the juvenile and criminal justice systems.

The toll of tough discipline is clear, the federal leaders said: Secondary schools suspend or expel 2 million students each year. “That’s a staggering amount of lost learning time and lost opportunity to provide more meaningful support,” Duncan said.

Nationally, he said, as many as 95 percent of suspensions are for nonviolent offenses such as disruption, disrespect, tardiness and dress code violations.

Consequences are important, he said, but “I must ask: Is putting students out of school the best solution, the best remedy, for those problems?”

Duncan said students should be removed from classrooms “only as a last resort,” and only for serious infractions such as endangering the safety of other students or teachers.

The new guidelines come more than two years after Duncan and Holder jointly created a federal initiative to support positive discipline practices and address the “school-to-prison pipeline” that links student offenses to judicial involvement.

Their effort followed a landmark 2011 study of nearly 1 million Texas students that associated suspensions with academic failure, dropping out and involvement in the juvenile justice system.

Many advocates and educators cheered the federal action.

“This is historic,” said Judith Browne Dianis, codirector of the Advancement Project, a civil rights organization. “Disparities in school discipline have been documented since the 1970s, and we’ve never been able to get the federal government to step in and help stop it.”

Aimed at schools, school districts and states, the new guidelines are designed to promote best practices and help local officials comply with federal laws. They were released as part of a “guidance package” with multiple materials and an online compendium of discipline laws and regulations across the country.

Students of color and those with disabilities are disproportionately affected by discipline, federal data show. Among nondisabled students, African-Americans are more than three times as likely as their white peers to be suspended or expelled, officials said.

“We must tackle these brutal truths head-on,” Duncan said. “It is the only way – the only way – to change the reality that our children face every single day.”

The administration will propose a $50 million program to provide grants to more than 1,000 schools to train teachers and staff in research-based strategies to improve approaches to student behavior and school climate, officials said.

According to a comprehensive Department of Education report on the 2009-10 school year, Virginia suspended 7.9 percent of its students and Maryland 6.9 percent. Duncan noted Wednesday that South Carolina suspended 12.7 percent of its students – at the high end of the spectrum – while North Dakota suspended just 2.2 percent.

“That huge disparity is not caused by differences in children,” he said. “It is caused by differences in training, professional development and discipline policies.”

The State is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service