Health care industry vested in success of Obamacare

11/24/2013 12:00 AM

11/23/2013 9:16 PM

President Barack Obama’s health care law, struggling to survive its botched rollout, now depends more than ever on insurance companies, doctor groups and hospitals – major forces in the industry that are committed to the law’s success despite persistent tensions with the White House.

Many health care industry leaders are increasingly frustrated with the Obama administration’s clumsy implementation of the Affordable Care Act. Nearly all harbor reservations about parts of the sweeping law. Some played key roles in killing previous Democratic efforts to widen healthcare coverage.

But since 2010, they have invested billions of dollars to overhaul their businesses, design new insurance plans and physician practices, and develop better ways to monitor quality and control costs.

Few industry leaders want to go back to a system that most had concluded was failing, as costs skyrocketed and the ranks of the uninsured swelled.

Nor do they see much that is promising from the law’s Republican critics. The GOP has focused on repealing Obamacare, but has devoted less energy to developing a replacement.

Health care industry officials generally view several GOP proposals, such as limiting coverage for the poor and scuttling new insurance marketplaces created by the law, as more damaging than helpful to the nation’s healthcare system.

“The principle of providing the opportunity for everyone to get health coverage and of joining everybody together in shared responsibility is the right one,” said James Roosevelt Jr., president of Tufts Health Plan, one of Massachusetts’ largest insurers. “No one has presented a credible alternative.”

The value of the alliance between the administration and major insurers, hospitals, clinics and others in the health care industry can readily be seen in steps they have taken to help the White House overcome the rocky start of the law’s new insurance marketplaces.

Insurers, for example, are working with the administration to enroll consumers directly in health plans for next year, bypassing the troubled website that residents of 36 states were supposed to be able to use to select a health plan.

Major retail pharmacies, such as CVS Caremark, have agreed to market the law’s benefits in their stores. And hospitals and health clinics in many states are helping patients sign up for coverage.

For many of these organizations, the prospect of new customers and a more rational system outweighs their sometimes intense irritation with the Obama administration.

Insurance executives, in particular, have gnashed their teeth at the president’s attacks on their industry, often delivered as the administration simultaneously sought insurers’ cooperation. In recent days, industry leaders were galled by the president’s proposal to shift responsibility for the cancellation of several million existing insurance policies onto insurers and away from the new law.

“Some feel like they did their part to make the law work. It’s very frustrating,” said Bruce Bodaken, former chief executive of Blue Shield of California and a leading industry advocate for expanding health coverage in the state.

Fifteen insurance executives, including Roosevelt, met with Obama for 90 minutes last week at the White House to discuss the president’s proposal, which would allow insurers to extend health plans that are being canceled because they fail to meet the new law’s standards.

The health law was explicitly designed to move consumers out of those policies. Consumers were supposed to be able to shop for new, more comprehensive, plans on marketplaces created by the Affordable Care Act. That has been difficult because of persistent problems with the federal enrollment website (although most state-operated sites have worked better).

Industry leaders, state regulators and even many consumer advocates see canceling the old plans as critical to sustaining the law’s marketplaces and improving coverage. The new system depends on moving all consumers into a market where both healthy and sick Americans can get health coverage. In the old system, only healthy consumers could usually get insurance in the so-called individual market.

Despite the frustrations, most insurers remain committed to moving to a new market that would achieve the central promise of the Affordable Care Act: that all consumers can buy health plans even if they have pre-existing medical conditions.

Editor's Choice Videos

Join the Discussion

The State is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Terms of Service