Politics & Government

McMaster: Shareholders right to vote against $110M severance package for SCANA execs

S.C. Gov. Henry McMaster on Wednesday joined his Democratic challenger, state Rep. James Smith of Columbia, in criticizing SCANA for setting aside $110 million in severance pay for utility executives.

Lawyers on Monday told a federal judge that SCANA, the parent company of SCE&G, had set aside $110 million to pay its executives if they lose their jobs in a buyout of the Cayce-based utility by Virginia-based Dominion Energy.

SCANA shareholders voted Tuesday against paying that severance money. But that vote was nonbinding and the severance pay, including in contracts, is likely to be paid out if the Dominion deal goes through.

“I think that is not a good corporate decision, and I think the decision of the shareholders was the better decision,” McMaster said Wednesday. “The people of the state, particularly under these circumstances, are rightly concerned — and some are highly angry — over ... the use of that money.”

SCANA has been criticized for its excessive executive pay and bonuses while those leaders failed to properly oversee the construction of two nuclear power reactors at the V.C. Summer Nuclear Station. That project was abandoned a year ago after a decade of work and $9 billion in costs.

SCE&G ratepayers already have paid more than $2 billion toward the cost of the two unfinished reactors.

Rep. Smith, the Democratic nominee for governor, reacted to news of the severance packages Monday, saying, “All of the executives getting this golden parachute should resign immediately.”

“This money should instead be going into a fund that provides relief to the ratepayers. They’re the ones who deserve it,” Smith said.

Smith also called on McMaster to give back campaign contributions from SCANA and its executives. SCANA bundled at least $115,000 in contributions to McMaster from the utility, its political action committee and employees in the weeks before it walked away from the nuclear project.

During the GOP primary, McMaster was challenged to return the SCANA contributions but declined to do so.


Despite those contributions, McMaster has said he has a record of being tough on SCANA.


For example, McMaster forced the state-owned Santee Cooper utility, SCANA’s junior partner in the V.C. Summer project, to disclose a copy of the secret 2015 Bechtel report. That report, commissioned by the two utilities, detailed insufficient oversight of the nuclear project. Last month, the governor also vetoed legislation to cut SCE&G’s rates by 15 percent, saying those rates should be cut by more — 18 percent.



Smith and his running mate, Rep. Mandy Powers Norrell, voted against the 15-percent rate cut, saying — like McMaster — it did not go far enough.


Smith also accepted campaign contributions from SCANA — receiving $500 from the company’s employee PAC in 2015, 2016 and 2017.


Smith campaign spokesman Brad Warthen said Smith gave those contributions to neighborhood associations and other nonprofits. His campaign disclosure report shows expenditures to the Shandon and Hollywood-Rose Hill neighborhood associations.


“For McMaster to compare those contributions to the more than $100,000 he has received from SCANA executives and board members is laughable,” Warthen said.



Tom Barton: 803-771-8304, @tjbarton83

This story was originally published August 1, 2018 at 6:22 PM.

Related Stories from The State in Columbia SC
Get one year of unlimited digital access for $159.99
#ReadLocal

Only 44¢ per day

SUBSCRIBE NOW