Opinion articles provide independent perspectives on key community issues, separate from our newsroom reporting.

Opinion Extra

Graham-Cassidy: An inspired health fix that came out of the blue

US Sen Lindsey Graham speaks to the media on Tuesday, accompanied by Senate Majority Whip Sen. John Cornyn, Sen. Bill Cassidy, Sen. John Thune and Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell.
US Sen Lindsey Graham speaks to the media on Tuesday, accompanied by Senate Majority Whip Sen. John Cornyn, Sen. Bill Cassidy, Sen. John Thune and Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell. AP

For months, I’ve been worried about the compelling simplicity of the Democrats’ single-payer health-care message. Since President Donald Trump was elected, Senate Republicans have been floundering somewhere between Obamacare and nothing. But an 11th-hour rally led by Sens. Bill Cassidy, R-La., and Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., has brought forth an inspired policy idea that is fresh and different.

The Graham-Cassidy bill does a number of things that are good for the Republican Party and good for health care in America.

First, it is a good answer to the Democrats’ bumper sticker call for “single-payer.” Rather than be responsible for a complex, tedious Obamacare-lite where Washington would remain the primary decision-maker, Republicans can now offer the idea of “local control” over a lot of health-care spending. Graham-Cassidy is Republicanism in its purest form: disempowering Washington and returning those powers back to where the framers intended — the states. Republicans have been talking about it for decades but doing very little to make it happen. Will it be Trump who leads us into a new era of power transferring to the states?

Ed Rogers
Ed Rogers Eli Turner

Second, if you want to drain the swamp, the Graham-Cassidy bill would be a huge first step. The swamp, actually, consists of vast pools of money that swamp-dwellers survive on in Washington. If you want to drain the swamp, then funnel the money out of Washington. When the money leaves Washington, the swamp-dwellers lose their sustenance.

Third, and maybe most important, the Graham-Cassidy bill would, for the first time ever, put some sort of quantifiable cap on an entitlement. Entitlement spending is America’s economic cancer. Under Graham-Cassidy, the predictability and utility of Medicaid costs would become more clear, perhaps setting a new precedent on how we rein in our out-of-control spending for other entitlements.

As Republicans close in on securing the votes needed to pass Graham-Cassidy, Democrats and special interest groups have gone into full panic mode, pulling out all of their usual tricks and scare tactics. Which, by the way, is all the more reason Republicans should rally together to pass the bill. Obamacare is broken and near its deathbed; why keep it alive? As The Wall Street Journal editorial board wrote, “the choice Republicans face isn’t between Graham-Cassidy or some bipartisan beau ideal. Their choice is to pass their own bill, which now means Graham-Cassidy, or fail again and cede the health-care advantage to the single-payer wing of the Democratic Party.”

Without much warning, a big idea has snuck up on us. Perhaps its time has come. No tactic should be left off the table to assemble the 50 votes needed in the Senate.

Contact Mr. Rogers at edrogers_write@bgrdc.com.

Get one year of unlimited digital access for $159.99
#ReadLocal

Only 44¢ per day

SUBSCRIBE NOW