What was Florida thinking by putting an injured Malik Zaire back in the game?
Florida’s interim coach said college football players can’t be put in harm’s way if they’re injured.
But that’s exactly what Randy Shannon and his Florida Gators coaching staff appeared to do during Saturday’s 28-20 loss to South Carolina.
During the second quarter, quarterback Malik Zaire injured his left leg on a 23-yard run and left the game. He struggled after getting tackled and left the field.
After sitting out just one play, Zaire returned to the field. The play the Gators called on Zaire’s first snap back in action, appeared to be designed running play for Zaire.
The same Zaire who had an injury to his leg.
Predictably, Zaire came up lame.
“After he collapsed, we took him out because of the severity of the injury. This is not the NFL, this is college football and no matter what the injury is, we can’t allow guys to put themselves in harm way,” Shannon said after it appeared that’s exactly what happened.
On his ill-fated return to the field in the SEC game, Zaire dropped back and gave a look like it was a passing play before tucking the ball and starting to run a draw. He made it three steps before collapsing to the grass without being touched by a Gamecock defender.
Really feeling for Malik Zaire
— Jac Collinsworth (@JacCollinsworth) November 11, 2017
Hurt his leg on a long run, tried to tough through it ... pic.twitter.com/OcbpIHR4pT
“Evaluation from the medical staff did a great job of running him through some stuff and making sure he was okay, and he was okay,” Shannon told the media after the game.
There was no word on what “stuff” the Gators’ medical team used to evaluate Zaire’s injury for the one play he missed before his failed return.
“Like anything else when that happened, we had to make sure the safety of him was more valuable than anything, so that is why we took him back out,” Shannon said.
From that point on, the Notre Dame transfer did not return to the game.
“I cannot put anyone in that situation,” Shannon said after the game.
Although Shannon told CBS during a halftime interview Zaire could return to the game in an emergency situation, according to seccountry.com.
As Shannon continued to explain, he said the whole situation brought the quarterback who transferred from Notre Dame to tears.
“He wanted to go back in, he came out at halftime and I came up to him and said, ‘I can’t do it to you. We will be okay here, we will be alright.’ He just started crying,” Shannon said.
Florida fans weren’t crying, but many were unhappy with the decision to put a clearly injured player in harms way.
Gators fans haven’t had much to cheer about this season, one that has seen former head coach Jim McElwain fired two weeks ago. The restless supporters took to social media to vent and critique the decision to play Zaire.
Can't believe they let Zaire back in the game. Then didn't call a run play. Interim report Coach and training staff should be fired
— J (@j_whipp13) November 11, 2017
What are y’all doing, Florida? Why are you putting Zaire back out there like that? Dude is hurt. Stop it.
— Reid Garrett (@JustReidAboutMe) November 11, 2017
SMH Florida really let Malik Zaire go back out with a clearly compromised knee/leg
— SSB d.c.james (@dcjames5) November 11, 2017
Call a designed QB run for a guy who got hurt 2 plays before? What kind of stupid are you, Nussmeier?
— Seth Kegley (@SethKegley) November 11, 2017
Randy Shannon should 100% be responsible for however bad this Zaire injury ends up being. Unbelievable. #UFvsSC
— Tyler Ward (@TylerWardFilms) November 11, 2017
That was flat out stupid right there. Guys already hurt and you call another QB run. Don’t understand why he came back in anyway
— Florida Gator Latest (@UFupdates) November 11, 2017
This is malpractice from Randy Shannon right now.
— Aaron (@roneman90) November 11, 2017
To put Zaire back in the game was questionable. To put him in and call a running play for the quarterback was just dummy.
— Pat Dooley (@pat_dooley) November 11, 2017
That is criminal from Randy Shannon and the UF coaching and training staff. Absolutely insane
— Clarke Walker (@SeeLarke) November 11, 2017
Putting Zaire back in one play after a potentially serious knee injury would be a fireable offense, if, you know, these coaches weren't already halfway out the door.
— Jonathan Arnholz (@JArnholz) November 11, 2017
Malik Zaire hurts ankle. First play back, they decide to run him. hurts ankle more. Good playcalling.....
— Jackson Schoop (@JacksonSchoop) November 11, 2017
This story was originally published November 11, 2017 at 9:28 PM.