Go Columbia

Where to get the best french fries in Columbia

mwalsh@thestate.com

For Go Columbia’s latest food crawl, we turned our attention to french fries.

In this tour de fries, the staple side dish took center stage. We paid special attention to fries that achieved the balance between a perfectly crunchy exterior and soft, fluffy interior. We also were open-minded about fries with different cuts and toppings.

Here are our deep-fried and salty takeaways.

From left, sweet potato fries, bleu cheese + pimento cheese fries, and truffle Parmesan fries from Grill Marks
From left, sweet potato fries, bleu cheese + pimento cheese fries, and truffle Parmesan fries from Grill Marks Jane Dail jdail@thestate.com

Best For Sharing

Grill Marks – Fries Three Ways

No need to compromise on your fry choice at Grill Marks. You can have the fries you want, and so can whomever you’re with. That’s because instead of one basket, Grill Marks lets you order a combo of three mini baskets, with options like skinny fries; fat fries; sweet potato fries; blue and pimento cheese fries (our pick) and white truffle Parmesan fries.

Erin Shaw eshaw@thestate.com

Best Plain Fries

The Whig – Plain fry basket

Perfectly cooked and good enough to eat without ketchup. Our theory is that it’s so dark in The Whig that your taste sensors have to work extra hard in the absence of sight. That, or the fry man just knows what he’s doing.

Erin Shaw eshaw@thestate.com

Most Talked About

Pawley’s Front Porch – Sweet potato fries

Pawley’s sweet potato fries get a lot of hype, and for good reason. It’s hard to compete with the restaurant’s burgers, though, so they remain left of center plate.

RELATED: Columbia pizza joints ranked, from cheesiest to greasiest

Erin Shaw eshaw@thestate.com

Strangest Toppings

Takosushi – Green Chili Cheese Fries

If french fries at a fusion Japanese/Mexican restaurant sound strange, you are not alone.

The green chili cheese fries come with queso, chilis and beans. Now, beans go with a lot of things, but fries are not one of them. And reserve the tasty queso for nachos.

Pimento cheese fries from Rockaway’s
Pimento cheese fries from Rockaway’s Susan Ardis sardis@thestate.com

Best Cheese Fries

Rockaway – Pimento cheese fries

The crinkle fries on their own might not be a winner, but pimento cheese cures all ills. And Rockaway’s pimento cheese is delicious.

RELATED: All barbecue all the time – 8 Columbia restaurants we tried

Thirsty Fellow
Thirsty Fellow Provided photo Will Wheeler

Most Likely To Be Dessert In Disguise

Thirsty Fellow – Sweet potato fries

Some people like their sweet potatoes extra sweet. Thirsty Fellow is the place for those people. Topped with sugar and served with a sweet cream sauce.

Bacon Cheese fries from J. Peters on Beltline
Bacon Cheese fries from J. Peters on Beltline Susan Ardis sardis@thestate.com

Biggest Calorie Bomb

J Peters Grill & Bar - Smothered potato skins

You might hate yourself after eating these thick-cut potato halves smothered in three cheeses and bacon, but hey, it’s a good day to die! These fries are really a bacon entree with a french fry topping. Fantastic.

Dwaun Sellers dsellers@thestate.com

Most Likely to Change Your Life

Goat’s – Poutine

We can thank the Canadians for this fried potato dish topped with gravy and cheese, and we can thank Goat’s for making it just right. Deliciously savory, cheesy and seriously rich. Dig in with a fork, and keep the forkfuls coming.

Best Fries for the Person Who Asks for Everything on the Side

Mack’s Cash Grocery – Chili fries

Mack’s has graciously started doling out chili fries with the chili in a separate container. Pour as little or as much as you want. Especially helpful for takeout orders sans mess.

Sweet potato fries from Carolina Ale House in the Vista
Sweet potato fries from Carolina Ale House in the Vista Susan Ardis sardis@thestate.com

Best Sweet Potato Fries

Carolina Ale House

The sriracha-seasoned, waffle-cut fries served with chipotle ranch dressing are tangy and hot, but not tongue-scorching. Added bonus of being waffle-cut. A winner!

Matt Walsh mwalsh@thestate.com

Best Chili Cheese Fries

The Kingsman

You get a huge platter of delicious, classic fries, topped with homemade chili, cheddar cheese sauce and jalapeños. It’s an entire meal disguised as an appetizer.

Matt Walsh mwalsh@thestate.com

Best Fries With A Twist

Jake’s Bar & Grill - Pizza fries

Two words: Pizza. Fries. This genius, cheesy duet is impossible not to like. You get the zest of the Italian herbs and the slight kick from the pepperoni in one savory fry combo.

Where We Went

The Kingsman, 936 Axtell Drive, Cayce. (803) 796-8622, www.thekingsmanrestaurant.com

Jake’s Bar & Grill, 2112 Devine St. (803) 708-4788, jakesofcolumbia.com

Carolina Ale House, 708 Lady St. (803) 227-7150, www.carolinaalehouse.com

Mack’s Grocery, 1809 Laurel St. (803) 779-9858, www.facebook.com/macksonlaurel

Goat’s, 2017 Devine St. (803) 708-4495, www.facebook.com/Goats2

J Peters Grill & Bar, 2005 N Beltline Blvd. (803) 738-3760, jpetersgrill.com

Thirsty Fellow, 621 Gadsden St. (803) 799-1311, www.thirstyfellow.com

Rockaway Athletic Club, 2719 Rosewood Drive. (803) 256-1075, www.facebook.com/Rockawayathleticclub

The Whig, 1200 Main St. (803) 931-8852, www.thewhig.org

Pawley’s Front Porch, 827 Harden St. (803) 771-8001, pawleysfrontporch.com

Takosushi, 1115 Assembly St. (803) 771-7131, www.tako-sushi.com

Grill Marks, 711 Gervais St. (803) 661-8932, www.grillmarks.com/

This story was originally published October 5, 2016 at 11:15 AM with the headline "Where to get the best french fries in Columbia."

Get one year of unlimited digital access for $159.99
#ReadLocal

Only 44¢ per day

SUBSCRIBE NOW